City of Hudson, OH · pop. 23K
Wed18Nov7:30 PM
Architectural & Historic Board of Review
Wed Nov 18, 7:30 PM · Town Hall 27 East Main Street · Final · 4 days ago
This agenda in plain words
Leer en españolThis is a regular meeting of Hudson's Architectural & Historic Board of Review, which reviews the look of buildings, especially in the historic district. Most items are requests to change or build on properties, such as new roofs, doors, siding, a barn, and new houses or townhomes. Each item lists staff comments the board will consider; no final decisions are shown in the agenda.
- A request to replace a historic clay tile roof with asphalt shingles. The board earlier asked for research on other roofing materials; staff say no new information has been submitted. Touches: 190 N Main Street, in the Historic District. p. 2
- A request to replace the roof on 186 N Main Street. The roof is asphalt now, and staff question whether the proposed color fits the historic tile-roof block. This item was continued from October 28. Touches: 186 N Main Street, in the Historic District. p. 2
- A request to replace a front door with an aluminum-clad wood door with simulated divided panes. Staff say the trim material still needs to be checked. This item was continued from October 28. Touches: 84 N Oviatt Street, in the Historic District. p. 3
- A request for changes to a bank building: new awnings, windows, and a vestibule (small entry room). Revised drawings show the changes, and staff question the wall material on a west-side bump-out. This item was continued from October 14. Touches: 37 S. Main Street (PNC Bank); not in the Historic District. p. 3
- A request to add a second story over the existing forward garage wing and expand a one-car garage. Staff raise questions about how big the front part would look and about the roof shape. The board approved the original plans on June 24. Touches: 43 Wellgate Dr. p. 4
- A request to change the approved plans for an addition with a sunroom, stair tower, and front porch. Changes include materials, dormers, windows, and rooflines. Staff ask the applicant to review the scope and question the standing seam metal use. Touches: 322 Simon Rd. p. 5
- A request to build a new house. Staff ask for changes to the wall materials, windows, and roof, and for a roof plan and product spec sheets. This item was continued from October 28. Touches: 1556 W. Prospect St. p. 6
- A request for townhomes on Owen Brown Street. The board denied the 3-story design in September, and the BZBA later reversed that decision on appeal. Staff suggest the board give comments now and table the proposal to the December meeting. Touches: 86 Owen Brown Street; townhome buyers and neighbors. p. 7
- A request for a new ground sign at 5700 Darrow Rd. Staff ask the applicant to show lighting at ground level and landscaping around the base. Touches: 5700 Darrow Rd. p. 7
- A request to replace the vinyl siding on the main house. The board is asked whether the wings may have a different siding reveal (spacing of the boards) than the main part of the house. Touches: 7337 Valerie Ln. p. 8
Words on this agenda, explained
- Consent Applications
- A group of items staff recommend approving as submitted, usually approved together without separate discussion.
- Continued
- Postponed to a later meeting, so the item was not decided at the earlier meeting.
- Fenestration
- The windows and doors on a building wall.
- Wing
- A part of a house that sticks out from the main body of the house.
- BZBA
- The city's Board of Zoning and Building Appeals, which hears appeals of decisions like this board's.
Written by AI from the agenda, Nov 14. Each point links to its page: read it there before you rely on it. Nothing here says how the board will vote.
Agenda items (28)
- I.Call To Order
- II.Roll Call
- III.Public Comment
- IV.Consent Applications p. 1
- A.72 Division Street (Historic District) Alteration (Roof Replacement) Submitted by Payne & Payne Builders, Inc. a) Staff recommends approval as submitted. p. 1
- B.6799 Dana Ave Alteration (Siding Application) Submitted by Maggie Murray a) Staff recommends approval as submitted. p. 1
- C.669 Barlow Rd Accessory Structure (Barn) Submitted by Chris Brown a) Staff recommends approval as submitted. p. 1
- V.Old Business
- A.190 N Main Street (Historic District) Alteration (Roof Replacement) Submitted by Renee Ingram, Campo Roof a) Staff notes this application was continued at the October 28, 2026 AHBR meeting. b) Staff notes that during the October 28th meeting, the Board requested the applicant further research alternative roofing materials for the proposed replacement of the existing historic clay tile roof that would better align with the surrounding historic district. The Board expressed concern regarding the proposed material change and its compatibility with the historic character of the property. Staff notes no additional information has been submitted by the applicant for the Boards consideration at this time, though the applicant would have the opportunity to address these comments at the meeting. c) The Secretary of Interior Standards state “Distinctive features, finishes, and construction… p. 2
- B.186 N Main Street (Historic District) Alteration (Roof Replacement) Submitted by Renee Ingram, Campo Roof a) Staff notes this application was continued at the October 28, 2026 AHBR meeting. Staff notes no revisions have been made to the request. b) Staff notes the existing roof has asphalt shingles; however, is surrounded by historically significant tile roofs. Question if the proposed color would be compatible with this historic block of N. Main Street. p. 2
- C.84 N Oviatt Street (Historic District) Exterior Alteration (Door Replacement) Submitted by Abigail Lilli, Gunton Corporation a) Staff notes this application was continued at the October 28, 2026 AHBR meeting. b) A site visit took place on November 10, 2026. c) The Secretary of Interior Standards state “Deteriorated historic features shall be repaired rather than replaced. Where the severity of deterioration requires replacement of a distinctive feature, the new feature shall match the old in design, color, texture, and other visual qualities and, where possible, materials. Replacement of missing features shall be substantiated by documentary, physical, or pictorial evidence” Staff notes additional documentation of the existing door has been submitted for the Boards review. d) Staff notes an aluminum clad wood replacement door is proposed with simulated divided lites. The proposed door… p. 3
- D.37 S. Main Street (PNC Bank) Commercial Alterations (Awnings, Windows, and Vestibule) Submitted by Michelle Cocos, GPD Group a) Staff notes this application was continued at the October 14, 2026 AHBR meeting. b) Staff notes the applicant has submitted revised elevations depicting proposed changes to the west and south side vestibule, retention of the existing south side barn doors, and asphalt roofing material to resemble slate. Staff notes the proposed building signage is not part of this application. c) Staff notes the building was constructed in 1893; however is not located within the Historic District or a designated individual landmark. d) Question proposed wall material at west-side elevation bump out. p. 3
- E.43 Wellgate Dr Addition (1 Car Garage and Storage) Submitted by Bridget Tipton a) Staff notes this application received review and approval at the June 24, 2026 AHBR meeting. b) Staff notes the applicant is requesting a modification of the approved plans including a 2nd story addition to the existing forward garage wing and 1-car garage expansion. c) Section IV-4 (h)(1) of the Architectural Design Standards states that an additional wing may be added to any mass of the building. This wing must be attached at the rear or side of the building and may not extend forward of the main body. Additionally, Section IV-4 (b)(2) of the Architectural Design Standards states that the front face of the main body must sit forward at least 18” from the front face of the wings. Staff notes the existing house has a forward 1 story garage wing; however, the 2nd story addition would substantially expand… p. 4
- F.322 Simon Rd Addition (Sunroom, Stair Tower, and Front Porch) Submitted by Rebecca Pantuso, Pantuso Architecture a) Staff notes this application received AHBR review and approval at the May 27, 2026 AHBR meeting. b) Staff notes the applicant is requesting a modification to the approved plans including changes to the proposed exterior materials, additional dormers, egress windows, chimney modifications, window headers, and rooflines. c) Staff suggests the applicant take this meeting to discuss the proposed project with the Board and verify the scope of work. d) Question the proposed use of standing seam. Staff notes the main body would be predominately asphalt shingle. p. 5
- G.1556 W. Prospect St New House (Single-Family Dwelling) Submitted by Chris Brown a) Staff notes this application was continued at the October 28, 2026 AHBR meeting. b) Section IV-4 (g)(2) of the Architectural Design Standards states that projections which extend out from the mass to which they are attached more than five feet will be treated as wings, except for open porches, and single story additions off the rear of multi-story dwellings. If the roof line of the addition intersects the roof line of the existing dwelling, then the addition shall be classified as a wing. Staff notes the proposed home office projection extends approximately 8 ft from the main mass; however, staff notes that the proposed house has an approximate 130 ft setback from the road and may be screened by existing vegetation. c) Section IV-4 (d)(3) of the Architectural Design Standards states that the materials… p. 6
- H.86 Owen Brown Street Townhomes Submitted by Rhonda Singer, Fairmont Properties a) Staff notes the AHBR reviewed the proposal at the September 9, 2026 meeting. The AHBR denied the proposal based on the 3-story design. b) The applicant appealed the AHBR decision to the BZBA. The BZBA reviewed the appeal at the October 15, 2026 meeting. The BZBA reversed the AHBR decision and approved the requested waiver for 3 story buildings, separate from Section IV-11 (a). c) The proposal is now before the AHBR to review for compliance with the remaining AHBR standards, separate from the 2-story reference in IV-11(a). d) Staff notes the applicant has submitted cross-section profiles and additional product specification sheets, though no new changes have been made at this time to the elevations. Staff suggests the board make any additional comments that could be incorporated into revisions for the… p. 7
- VI.New Business
- A.5700 Darrow Rd Sign (Ground Sign) Submitted by John Benedict, Brilliant Sign a) Section V-3(b) of the Architectural Design Standards states that the design and placement of ground signs and associated lighting fixtures should complement the overall visual appearance of the site. Additionally, section V-3(b)(3) states that approved year-round landscaping shall be used around the base of the sign to screen lighting fixtures and sources in compliance with the Land Development Code. Revise proposed design to depict lighting at ground level to meet these requirements. p. 7
- B.7337 Valerie Ln Alterations (Siding Replacement) Submitted by Rita Cahill a) Staff notes the applicant is proposing to replace the vinyl siding on the main house. As a result, the siding on the main mass would have a different reveal than the siding on the wings. b) Staff notes Section IV-4 (d)(2) of the Architectural Design Standards states that the wings may have a different material for the wall than the main body; however, Section IV-4 (f)(3) states additions should be designed to be compatible with the main structure by incorporating materials and a foundation to match. c) As this is not a typical request, staff is requesting a collective determination from the AHBR on whether the wings are permitted to have a different siding reveal than the main mass. Staff notes staff may refer minor development applications to AHBR as necessary under Section 1202.06(k) p. 8
- C.6268 Paderborne Dr Accessory Structure (Pavilion) Submitted by Scott Dohner a) Section III-1(g)(8) of the Architectural Design Standards state that large expanses of blank wall are to be avoided. Fenestration placement should be at a maximum of approximately every 12 feet. Provide additional fenestration detail on the rear elevation to better meet the requirement. Staff notes a false window could be considered. p. 8
- D.205 Hudson Street Addition (Master Bedroom) Submitted by Leon Sampat a) Section IV-4 (h)(1) of the Architectural Design Standards states that an additional wing may be added to any mass of the building. This wing must be attached at the rear or side of the building and may not extend forward of the main body. Additionally, Section IV-4 (b)(2) of the Architectural Design Standards states that the front face of the main body must sit forward at least 18” from the front face of the wings. Staff notes the existing house has a forward wing; however, the proposal would expand the existing wing by approximately 6 feet. p. 8
- E.7687 Ravenna Rd New House (Single Family Dwelling) Submitted by Ally Tkalcic, Schumacher Homes a) Section IV-3 (g)(2) of the Architectural Design Standards states that projections which extend out from the mass to which they are attached more than five feet will be treated as wings, except for open porches, and single-story additions off the rear of multi-story dwellings. If the roof line of the addition intersects the roof line of the existing dwelling, then the addition shall be classified as a wing. Staff notes that the proposed owners retreat closet projection extends forward approximately 7 ft from the main mass; however, staff notes that the proposed house has an approximate 100 ft setback from the road. b) Section IV-(d)(3) of the Architectural Design Standards states the materials used in any mass must be applied consistently on that mass on all sides of the structure. Staff… p. 9
- VII.Other Business
- A.2027 Meeting Schedule - Architectural & Historic Board of Review p. 9
- B.Minutes of Previous Architectural & Historic Board of Review Meeting: October 28, 2026 p. 9
- VIII.Staff Update
- IX.Adjournment
- * * *