Town of Brookhaven, NY · pop. 485K
Wed18Nov2:00 PM
Board of Zoning Appeals
Wed Nov 18, 2:00 PM · 1 Independence Hill, Farmingville · 4 days ago
Zoning Board Meeting
Agendabrookhavenny.api.civicclerk.comRecording ▸brookhavenny.portal.civicclerk.comAgendaBZA November 18, 2026 Civic AgendaAgendaBZA November 18, 2026 Civic Agenda
Minutesnot posted yet
Meeting page ↗brookhavenny.portal.civicclerk.comThis agenda in plain words
Leer en españolThis is a Board of Zoning Appeals meeting in the Town of Brookhaven, New York, on November 18, 2026. The board hears requests from property owners and businesses who want permission to build or change things in ways the town's rules do not normally allow, called variances and special permits. Many items are on the list, and the board's decisions on them are what is up for a vote.
- Request to build a motor vehicle wash on a lot smaller than required, with less width, less front yard space, and less setback from nearby homes. Also asks for relief from several special permit rules, including landscaping. Touches: Northeast corner of Portion Road and Hans Boulevard, Ronkonkoma. p. 1
- Request for several wall signs, a taller wall sign, and a ground sign larger than allowed and placed closer to the road than required, for the proposed car wash. Touches: Northeast corner of Portion Road and Hans Boulevard, Ronkonkoma. p. 1
- Request to build a two-story health club with outdoor recreation, a pool deck and an elevated parking deck, replacing the existing fitness center, with several setbacks and a floor area ratio above the limit. Touches: East side of Mark Tree Road, East Setauket (existing fitness center to be demolished). p. 1
- Request for four wall signs on the west side of the proposed health club, where one per side is allowed, and a ground sign larger than allowed. Touches: East side of Mark Tree Road, East Setauket. p. 2
- Request to allow three outdoor light poles to be taller than 20 feet. Touches: East side of Mark Tree Road, East Setauket. p. 2
- Request to split one parcel into three plots and build a one-family home on plot 1, with lot area, lot width and side yard variances. Touches: North side of Locust Avenue, Farmingville. p. 2
- Request to split a Montauk Highway lot into two plots and allow a take-out restaurant that does not meet the Main Street Business District design rules for buffers, sidewalks and street trees. Touches: South side of Montauk Highway, Patchogue; a take-out restaurant. p. 2
- Request to split a lot into two plots and build a home on plot 1 with several variances, including for the lot area, lot width, front yard, rear yard and side yards. Touches: Somers Place, Mastic. p. 4
- Request to allow a basement entrance, a shed, a pool and a garage that are too close to property lines, and rear lot coverage above the 25% limit, at an existing home. Touches: West side of Stanley Drive, Centereach. p. 4
- Request to allow a proposed in-ground pool and a 6-foot fence in the front yard on Birch Street, which is not normally allowed. Touches: Northwest corner of Lowery Avenue and Birch Street, Lake Grove. p. 5
Written by AI from the agenda, Nov 17. Each point links to its page: read it there before you rely on it. Nothing here says how the board will vote.
41 items on this agenda match the land-use topicsVariances (41)
Agenda items (54)Show all 54
- 2.RA Portion Road LLC., 1201 Route 112, Suite 900, Port Jefferson Station, New York. Location: Northeast corner Portion Road and Hans Boulevard, Ronkonkoma. Location: Northeast corner Portion Road and Hans Boulevard, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests permission for 3 proposed wall signs on east elevation and 2 proposed wall signs on west elevation (1 permitted per elevation); height variance for one of said signs on west and east elevations each exceeding 9'3" and 40 square feet permitted (10'1.75" and 111.4 square feet); height variance for proposed wall sign on south elevation to exceed 18' high, 40 square feet permitted (25'1', 111.4 square feet); permission for proposed 56.74 square foot ground sign (24 square feet permitted) to be located less than the required 17 feet required at Portion Rd. (1'). p. 1
- 5.LTF Real Estate Company Inc., d/b/a Life Time, 2900 Corporate Place, Chanhassen, Minnesota. Location: East side Mark Tree Road 902.24' North of Nesconset Port Jefferson Highway (East side Washington Avenue - not open), East Setauket. Applicant requests height variance for 3 nonresidential luminares to exceed 20 feet high from grade (24.5 feet provided). p. 1
- 6.Jose Mendonco, care of Woodhull Expediting, 800 Veterans Memorial Highway Suite Cl-101, Hauppauge, New York. Location: North side Locust Avenue, 360.20' West of Blue Point Road, Farmingville. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 3 plots, 1, 2 and 3 requiring lot area, lot frontage, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 53900 0500 033000, 034000 and 035000) p. 2
- 7.Jose Mendonco, care of Woodhull Expediting, 800 Veterans Memorial Highway Suite Cl-101, Hauppauge, New York. Location: North side Locust Avenue, 285.20' West of Blue Point Road, Farmingville. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2. p. 2
- 8.Jose Mendonco, care of Woodhull Expediting, 800 Veterans Memorial Highway Suite Cl-101, Hauppauge, New York. Location: North side Locust Avenue, 185.20' West of Blue Point Road, Farmingville. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, minimum and total side yard variances for existing one family dwelling on plot 3. p. 2
- 11.16 Donella Walk LLC, 35 Boylan Lane, Blue Point, New York. Location: North side Montauk Highway 235.94' East of Rowland Avenue, Blue Point. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 2 plots, 1 and 2, requiring lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed conversion of existing farm stand/country store to a one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 98080 0600 025000) p. 3
- 116 Donella Walk LLC, 35 Boylan Lane, Blue Point, New York. Location: North side Montauk Highway 235.94' East of Rowland Avenue, Blue Point. Applicant requests total side yard variance for existing one story addition to said farm stand (to be converted to dwelling) on plot 1. p. 3
- 14.Arborvitaes Estate Inc., 487 Furrows Road, Holbrook, New York. Location: South side Portion Road, 100.52' West of Grace Court, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 3 plots, 1, 2 and 3 requiring lot area, lot frontage and minimum side yard variances for existing one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 65000 0100 015000, 016000, 017000) p. 3
- 15.Conservatory Realty Corp. 487 Furrows Road, Holbrook, New York. Location: Southwest corner of Portion Road and Grace Court, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests lot area variance for existing one family dwelling on plot 2. p. 3
- 16.Grace Court Ronkonkoma Properties LLC, 487 Furrows Road, Holbrook, New York. Location: West side Grace Court, 109.37' South of Portion Road, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback and rear yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 3. p. 3
- 17.Fire Island Pine Holdings LLC, care of Jennifer Leeds, Leeds Expediting LLC, 28 North Country Road, Suite 101, Mount Sinai, New York. Location: East side Picketty Ruff Walk 80.91' North of Fire Island Boulevard, Fire Island Pines (Fire Island National Seashore). Applicant requests the following relief for proposed redevelopment of existing hotel and restaurant (Blue Whale): height variances (28' high permitted - 35' from hotel bulkhead roof and 37.5' high from Blue Whale bulkhead roof provided); total building area of all principal and accessory structures (50% required - 92.73% provided); also, front yard setback (15 required - 3.5' from hotel elevator lobby, 0.23' from hotel kiosk, 11.69' from said restaurant, 7.96' from elevated deck and 3.89' from seven (7) cabanas provided). (0200 98640 0200 018000) p. 3
- 20.Somers Place 38 LLC, care of CKG Permit Service Inc. Post Office Box 87, Bellport, New York. Location: South side Somers Place, 320.00' West of Fulton Avenue, Mastic. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 2 plots, 1 and 2 requiring lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, rear yard and minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 78600 0600 038000) p. 4
- 21.Somers Place 38 LLC, care of CKG Permit Service Inc. Post Office Box 87, Bellport, New York. Location: South side Somers Place, 597.93' West of Fulton Avenue, Mastic. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, rear yard, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2. p. 4
- 22.Somers Place 39 LLC, care of CKG Permit Service, Post Office Box 87, Bellport, New York. Location: South side Somers Place, 320' West of Fulton Ave., Mastic. Applicant requests division of parcel into 2 plots, 1 and 2, requiring lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, rear yard, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 78600 0600 039000) p. 4
- 23.Somers Place 39 LLC, care of CKG Permit Service, Post Office Box 87, Bellport, New York. Location: South side Somers Place, 410' West of Fulton Avenue, Mastic. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, rear yard, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2. p. 4
- 25.Brian Montroy and Randi Bivens, care of Andrew Malguarnera, 713 Main Street, Port Jefferson, New York. Location: West side Stanley Drive, 553.39' North of Market Street, Centereach. Applicant requests permission for existing basement entrance exceeding the 5' permitted encroachment (7'); height, side yard and rear yard variances for existing 13' high shed (12' high permitted) (conversion of detached garage); side yard variance for existing semi in-ground swimming pool with pool deck; side yard and rear yard variances for existing detached garage; also, permission for rear lot coverage to exceed the 25% permitted (53%). (0200 48600 0900 033000)(BZA2908) p. 4
- 26.Daniel P. and Marissa Dicpinigaitis, 6 Cougar Court, Holtsville, New York. Location: South side Cougar Court 278.35' East of Morris Avenue, Holtsville. Applicant requests front yard setback variance for existing deck exceeding the 6 foot encroachment (7.5 feet). (0200 69300 0300 038000)(BZA2896) p. 5
- 27.Michael Norton and Rachel Strzeletski, care of Andrew Malguarnera, 713 Main Street, Port Jefferson, New York. Location: Northwest corner Lowery Avenue and Birch Street, Lake Grove. Applicant requests permission for proposed inground swimming pool located in the front yard (Birch Street); height variance for proposed 6 foot fence located in the front yard (Birch Street)(not permitted). (0200 53200 0100 068000)(BZA2918) p. 5
- 28.Harold Gonzalez, care of Beach Expediting, Post Office Box 427, West Hampton, New York. Location: West side McKinley Drive, 80' South of Pine Road, Mastic Beach. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 2 plots, 1 and 2 requiring lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, rear yard and minimum side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 97690 1500 018001 and 018002)(BZA2901) p. 5
- 29.Oasis Beach Rentals LLC, care of Beach Expediting, Post Office Box 427, West Hampton, New York. Location: West of McKinley Drive, 220' South of Pine Road, Mastic Beach. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback, rear yard and minimum side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2. (BZA2902) p. 5
- 31.Ralph DiRosa, 93 Cedarhurst Avenue, Medford, New York. Location: East side Cedarhurst Avenue, 320.25' South of Granny Road, Medford. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback and rear yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2.(BZA2921) p. 5
- 32.Ralph DiRosa, 93 Cedarhurst Avenue, Medford, New York. Location: East side Cedarhurst Avenue, 330.25' South of Granny Road, Medford. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, front yard setback and rear yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 3.(BZA2914) p. 5
- 33.Ralph DiRosa, 93 Cedarhurst Avenue, Medford, New York. Location: East side Cedarhurst Avenue, 340.25' South of Granny Road, Medford. Applicant requests lot area and lot frontage variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 4.(BZA2915) p. 5
- 34.Yasma Javad, 1 Merrick Road, Shirley, New York. Location: North side Merrick Road 165.98' East of Smith Road, Shirley. Applicant requests lot area, lot frontage, minimum and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling (existing foundation walls/footings to be demolished). (0200 90600 0100 018000) (BZA2873) p. 5
- 37.#43 of 9/16/26 John Bianco, care of Andrew Malguarnera, 713 Main Street, Port Jefferson, New York. Location: East side Lincoln Road, 463.65' South of Middle Island Avenue, Medford. Applicant requests height variance for proposed conversion of existing detached garage to shed exceeding the 12' high permitted (13' high); also, height variance for existing 16.55' high, 1500 square foot detached garage (16' high, 1200 square feet permitted). (0200 63500 0100 011000) p. 6
- 38.#4-6 of 10/21/26 Gregory Leonard, 37 Christian Avenue, Setauket, New York. Location: North side Christian Avenue, 113.27' West of Locust Avenue, Setauket. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 3 plots, 1, 2, and 3, requiring lot area and lot frontage variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1 (existing dwelling to be demolished). (0200 10900 0200 008000) p. 6
- 39.Gregory Leonard, 37 Christian Avenue, Setauket, New York. Location: North side Christian Avenue, 92.96' West of Locust Avenue, Setauket. Applicant requests lot area and lot frontage variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2.
- 40.Gregory Leonard, 37 Christian Avenue, Setauket, New York. Location: North side Christian Avenue, 72.65' West of Locust Avenue, Setauket. Applicant requests lot area and lot frontage variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 3.
- 41.#14-17 of 10/21/26 Anthony Martino and Frank Winheim, 344 Portion Road, Ronkonkoma, New York. Location: East side Virginia Avenue, 225' North of Ann Street, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 4 plots, 1,2,3 and 4, requiring no variances for existing one family dwelling on plot 1 (lot conforms). (0200 56400 0100 008000, 009000, 0200 59600 0100 001000, 002000) p. 6
- 42.Anthony Martino and Frank Winheim, 344 Portion Road, Ronkonkoma, New York. Location: East side Virginia Avenue, 365' North of Ann Street, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests no variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2 (lot conforms). p. 6
- 43.Anthony Martino and Frank Winheim, 344 Portion Road, Ronkonkoma, New York. Location: East side Virginia Avenue, 470.73' North of Ann Street, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests no variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 3 (lot conforms). p. 6
- 44.Anthony Martino and Frank Winheim, 344 Portion Road, Ronkonkoma, New York. Location: West side Arlington Road, 520' North of Ann Street, Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests front yard setback and rear yard variances and relief of Town Law 280A for proposed one family dwelling on plot 4. p. 6
- 45.#1 & 2 of 11/4/26 Frank Corso, 58 Brunswick Road, Lake Ronkonkoma, New York. Location: South side Diamond Street, 281.23' South of East Lake Terrace, Lake Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 2 plots, 1 and 2, requiring lot area and lot frontage variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 64700 0100 023000) p. 7
- 46.Frank Corso, 58 Brunswick Road, Lake Ronkonkoma, New York. Location: North side Newton Boulevard, 62.21' West of Kirby Lane, Lake Ronkonkoma. Applicant requests lot area and lot frontage variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2.
- 47.#17 & 18 of 11/4/26 Axium Associates Inc, care of Al Mandarino, 2 Hamilton Place, Lake Grove, New York. Location: South side Devon Lane, 222.05' West of Swezey Lane, Middle Island. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 2 plots, 1 and 2, located in J Business zone, requiring lot area, front yard setback, rear yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 43100 0100 027001) p. 7
- 48.Axium Associates Inc, care of Al Mandarino 2 Hamilton Place, Lake Grove, New York. Location: North side Middle Country Road (Route 25), 180.93' West of Swezey Lane, Middle Island. Applicant requests lot area, front yard setback, and rear yard variances for proposed commercial building on plot 2. p. 7
- 49.#2-5 of 9/16/26 1595 Ecke Ave LLC, 1155 Montauk Highway, East Patchogue, New York. Location: North side Coram Swezeytown Road, 2,814.51' East of Mount Sinai-Coram Road, Middle Island. Applicant requests division of a parcel into 4 plots, 1, 2, 3, and 4, requiring lot frontage and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 1. (0200 31700 0200 011004 and 011005) p. 7
- 50.1595 Ecke Ave LLC, 1155 Montauk Highway, East Patchogue, New York. Location: North side Coram Swezeytown Road, 2,929.62' East of Mount Sinai-Coram Road, Middle Island. Applicant requests lot frontage variance for proposed one family dwelling on plot 2. p. 7
- 51.Affordable Custom Home Builders Corp., 1155 Montauk Highway, East Patchogue, New York. Location: North side Coram Swezeytown Road, 2,949.73' East of Mount Sinai-Coram Road, Middle Island. Applicant requests lot frontage variance for proposed one family dwelling on plot 3. p. 8
- 52.Affordable Custom Home Builders Corp., 1155 Montauk Highway, East Patchogue, New York. Location: North side Coram Swezeytown Road, 2,954.42' East of Mount Sinai-Coram Road, Middle Island. Applicant requests lot frontage and total side yard variances for proposed one family dwelling on plot 4. p. 8
- 53.#27 of 10/21/26 Alan Zollo and Kristy Longman, care of Samuel L. Bifulco, Esq. 1300 Veterans Memorial Highway Suite-100, Hauppauge, New York. Location: North side Chapel Lane 301.59' West of Chapel Avenue, Patchogue. Applicant requests rear and side yard variances for existing 560.4 square foot pool house (400 square feet permitted). (0200 97940 0500 016000) p. 8